Craving Authentic Italian Food? Gargiulo's is a Must-Try

Imagine indulging in rich Neapolitan cuisine crafted from family recipes passed down for generations. Picture a cozy yet elegant space where every bite feels like a journey to the heart of Italy. At Gargiulo's Tinton Falls, this is exactly what you’ll find—a place where authentic flavors, warm hospitality, and unforgettable dining experiences come together to create something truly special.

A Legacy of Authenticity

The story of Gargiulo's Restaurant began in 1907 on Mermaid Avenue in Coney Island, Brooklyn. What started as a small family-owned business grew into a beloved institution, thanks to the Russo brothers—Victor, Michael, and Nino—who introduced their cherished recipes from Sorrento, Italy. In 2019, after over 55 years of delighting Brooklyn diners, the Russo family expanded their legacy to Tinton Falls, bringing along the same celebrated dishes and traditions.

More Than Just a Meal: A True Italian Experience

Dining at Gargiulo's is like stepping into Italy for an evening. The Gargiulo's Tinton Falls menu showcases iconic Italian dishes such as rigatoni bolognese and bucatini cacio e pepe, each made with premium ingredients and prepared with precision. To elevate your meal, explore our expertly curated wine list, offering perfect wine pairing options for every dish.

Families will love the inviting atmosphere, making Gargiulo's one of the top family-friendly Italian restaurants in Tinton Falls. It’s the ideal spot for gatherings, celebrations, or even a casual Sunday dinner.

Event Spaces for Every Occasion

For those searching for private event venues in Tinton Falls, Gargiulo's offers an unmatched setting. With multiple private dining rooms, we cater to events of all sizes. The upstairs dining room accommodates up to 40 guests, while a smaller room, equipped with A/V technology, is perfect for groups of 18 or fewer.

From intimate celebrations to grand affairs, Gargiulo's is a favorite for wedding reception venues, holiday party venues, and corporate event venues in Tinton Falls. Menus are fully customizable, ensuring your occasion is as unique as the memories you’ll make.

Why Locals Can’t Get Enough of Gargiulo's

Gargiulo's isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a destination. Known for authentic Italian flavors, impeccable service, and a welcoming ambiance, it has become a staple for those exploring the best Italian food in Tinton Falls. Guests often return for the signature dishes, personalized service, and the sense of community that Gargiulo’s fosters.

Unmissable Events: Wine Pairing Dinners

Food enthusiasts will delight in Gargiulo's exclusive wine pairing dinners. These thoughtfully curated experiences feature a four-course menu designed to showcase the perfect harmony between food and wine. Guests can even purchase our favorite wines from the evening to take home.

Plan Your Visit to Gargiulo's Today

Conveniently located in the heart of Tinton Falls, Gargiulo's is ready to welcome you and offers something special for everyone. From intimate dinners to large celebrations, it’s the perfect place to enjoy Neapolitan cuisine, host an event, or simply savor the best of Italian dining. With valet parking, outdoor dining options, and a cozy firepit, Gargiulo's ensures every visit is memorable.

Reserve your table today or reach out to plan your next event. Step into the rich tradition of Italian dining and experience the warmth, flavor, and charm of Gargiulo's Tinton Falls.