From Brooklyn to the ‘Burbs: The Gargiulo’s Story You Need to Know

When you think of authentic Italian restaurants that have stood the test of time, it's impossible not to mention Gargiulo’s. Established over a century ago in the vibrant neighborhood of Coney Island, Brooklyn, this beloved eatery has been a staple for those seeking the best Italian food near Tinton Falls. With its rich legacy of serving classic Neapolitan cuisine, Gargiulo’s expanded to the suburbs of Tinton Falls, New Jersey, in 2019, bringing with it generations of tradition, love for great food, and a reputation for creating unforgettable dining experiences.

A Legacy Rooted in Italian Tradition

The story of Gargiulo’s began in 1907 on Mermaid Avenue, where it quickly became a local favorite for its warm hospitality and authentic Neapolitan dishes. In the 1960s, the Russo Brothers—Victor, Michael, and Nino—took over ownership and infused their Sorrento, Italy-inspired recipes into the menu. For over 55 years, Gargiulo’s was synonymous with the best Italian food near Brooklyn, catering to locals and tourists alike.

When the Russo family decided to expand their beloved restaurant to Tinton Falls, they brought along more than just their recipes. They brought an entire legacy, allowing New Jersey residents to savor the same iconic flavors without crossing two bridges.

The New Gargiulo’s Tinton Falls Experience

Located at 720 Tinton Avenue, Gargiulo’s Tinton Falls offers a unique blend of old-world Italian charm with modern elegance. Stepping into the newly renovated space, you'll be greeted with a cozy yet upscale ambiance perfect for any occasion. Whether you're searching for private dining near Tinton Falls or an intimate gathering spot, Gargiulo’s caters to your needs with several private event venues available.

The Private Rooms: Perfect for Any Occasion

Looking for private event spaces near Tinton Falls? Gargiulo’s has you covered. Our upstairs dining room can host up to 40 guests comfortably, while smaller groups of up to 18 can enjoy the cozy ambiance of a private room equipped with a TV for presentations. These spaces are perfect for everything from family gatherings to corporate event venues or holiday party venues near Tinton Falls.

The private dining rooms also offer amenities such as A/V equipment, valet parking, a full bar, and an outdoor firepit—ideal for creating a memorable evening.

The Perfect Spot for Weddings, Corporate Events, and More

Are you planning a wedding? Gargiulo’s Tinton Falls is one of the top choices for wedding reception venues in Tinton Falls. Our charming venue, combined with the best authentic Italian food near Tinton Falls, creates a setting that your guests won’t forget. Whether you're envisioning an intimate wedding reception or a large family reunion, our flexible spaces and customizable menus ensure a seamless experience.

For corporate gatherings, our event spaces transform into ideal corporate event venues, perfect for impressing clients or celebrating team milestones. Holiday season approaching? Gargiulo’s is also among the top picks for holiday party venues in the area, thanks to our exceptional service and mouthwatering menu.

Wine Pairing Dinners: A Culinary Journey

One of the highlights of dining at Gargiulo’s Tinton Falls is our exclusive wine pairing dinners. Picture this: a four-course meal expertly curated by our chef, paired with wines that perfectly complement each dish. These events are perfect for those looking to explore new flavors and expand their palate. And if you love the wines you taste, you can take a bottle home to relive the experience.

Classic Neapolitan Cuisine: A Menu to Savor

The Gargiulo’s Tinton Falls menu pays homage to the beloved classics of Neapolitan cuisine that made our Brooklyn location famous. Whether it's our hearty Rigatoni Bolognese, creamy Bucatini Cacio e Pepe, or a perfectly cooked Veal Marsala, each dish is prepared with the finest ingredients and time-honored techniques passed down through generations.

For families, Gargiulo’s remains one of the most beloved family-friendly Italian restaurants in Tinton Falls, with dishes that cater to all ages. From classic pasta to kid-friendly options, there's something for everyone.

Celebrate Life’s Special Moments at Gargiulo’s Tinton Falls

Whether you're searching for the best Italian restaurant in Tinton Falls, planning a corporate event, or just looking to unwind with a delicious meal and fine wine, Gargiulo’s is the perfect destination. We pride ourselves on creating memorable experiences for every guest who walks through our doors.

Don't wait! Book your reservation today and discover why locals consider us the best in the area for private dining rooms and event spaces. Whether it's a casual dinner or a special celebration, Gargiulo’s Tinton Falls is where food, family, and friends come together.